P.L. 86‑272 in 2026: How Much Protection Does It Still Offer Out‑of‑State Sellers?
Public Law 86-272 was the subject of multistate income tax planning for companies engaged in the sale of tangible goods for over six decades. Section §§381‑384 of 15 U.S.C. restricts a state from imposing a net income tax on income from interstate commerce when the company’s only in‑state business activity is soliciting orders for tangible personal property, with the caveat of orders being approved and goods shipped from outside the state. The term “net income tax” can also include a franchise tax imposed on the basis of net income; all other types of business taxes are excluded from the term.
That narrow drafting has become increasingly important as states modernize their definitions of nexus and tax base rules. Congress has not expanded P.L. 86‑272 beyond net‑income‑based taxes or updated the statute for new business models. Therefore, courts and states confine preemption to the “clear and manifest purpose of Congress.”
What the Statute Still Shields—and What It Doesn’t
Companies that send salespeople into a state solely to solicit orders for physical goods to be approved and shipped from outside the state are protected from being required to file and pay net income taxes under P.L. 86-272. The long-standing policy of the Multistate Tax Commission’s statement on P.L. 86-272 has been updated numerous times since 1986 to reflect the latest decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court guidance on solicitation. This includes Wisconsin Department of Revenue v. Wrigley. Signatory states intend to exercise the full extent of their power to levy their states’ net income taxes in respect to activities other than solicitation and similar activities.
The Statement also underscores that “net income tax” includes franchise taxes measured by net income but not other business levies. That distinction means that taxes such as Tennessee’s franchise tax or Alabama’s business privilege/franchise‑type taxes generally fall outside P.L. 86‑272, even if a seller’s only in-state activity is solicitation. States remain free to impose non‑income‑based taxes such as capital or net-worth-based franchise taxes, gross receipts taxes, and flat privilege charges on states with sufficient nexus.
Digital Commerce and the MTC’s Internet Activities Framework
The pressing question in 2026 is how P.L. 86‑272 applies to modern online selling. South Dakota v. Wayfair triggered a wave of activities by the states in determining if online activities go beyond protected solicitation.
States, including New Jersey, have begun to outline online activities that are excludable from P.L. 86‑272 protections, including offering tangible goods for sale through a website where customers can search, purchase, and pay without additional in‑state business activities, and certain ancillary uses of payment platforms and NFTs. New Jersey’s Technical Bulletin TB‑108 and regulations explain that a corporation whose activities do not exceed P.L. 86‑272 is not subject to the income component of the Corporation Business Tax; however, it remains liable for the statutory minimum tax and must file a return if it has nexus or is registered in the state.
Similarly, New Jersey and other MTC states provide detailed examples of activities that do exceed P.L. 86‑272: repairs, installations, credit investigations, technical assistance, maintaining inventory or consigned goods, operating in‑state facilities, or offering non‑sales job positions in the state. These concepts translate to the internet context for activities like interactive technical support, remote diagnostics, training portals, and data‑driven services.
Throwback and the Cost of Losing Protection
P.L. 86‑272 affects nexus in the destination state and apportionment and throwback in the origin state. Under the MTC Statement, if a destination state is precluded from taxing the seller’s income due to P.L. 86-272, sales into that state remain subject to throwback to a state that does have jurisdiction to impose a net income tax. California and other signatory states follow this principle.
When a seller’s activities in the destination state exceed protected solicitation, whether through in‑person activities, non‑ancillary online services, or maintaining inventory there,
taxing net income is no longer prohibited under P.L. 86-272. The seller is considered “taxable” in the destination state for UDITPA purposes and thus those sales are excluded from the throwback calculation of the origin state. Conversely, where the destination state imposes only a non‑income‑based franchise or privilege tax outside P.L. 86‑272, a seller may still be treated as taxable there for throwback purposes, as illustrated by Alabama’s decision that Mississippi and Tennessee franchise taxes were not protected by P.L. 86‑272.
Practical Implications for Out‑of‑State Sellers in 2026
In 2026, P.L. 86‑272 continues to offer meaningful but narrow protection for out‑of‑state sellers of tangible goods whose only in‑state activity is solicitation of orders, with approvals and shipments made from outside the state.
Several trends sharply limit that shield:
- Broad state adoption of MTC guidance and detailed lists of protected and unprotected activities, including internet‑based functions.
- Increased use of non‑income taxes such as franchise and business privilege taxes, which generally fall outside the statute.
- Judicial and administrative willingness to treat interactive technical support and other customer‑facing online services as in‑state business activities beyond protected solicitation.
Dealers and manufacturers that rely on online tools like product configurators, live chat, remote diagnostics, training portals, or data‑driven services need to evaluate whether those activities are merely ancillary to solicitation or constitute separate in‑state services or operations. Where they cross the line, P.L. 86‑272 may no longer apply, opening the door to net income taxation in the destination state and reshaping throwback patterns from the origin state.
Since Congress has done nothing with P.L. 86-272, its evolution is currently in the hands of the states and relevant case law. Out‑of‑state sellers should monitor state adoption of MTC
internet‑activity standards, review their online customer‑facing functions, and model both nexus and apportionment impacts of losing P.L. 86‑272 protection in key markets.

.png)